Yes, the reviewers cannot see each other's comments. But there are some exceptions.
1. Open review. Here everyone, including the authors and readers can see everything.
2. AFTER REJECTION by the office. I am an expert reviewer and occasionally a journal sends me what other reviewers said, but only after they rejected the manuscript. Why?. This is because it tells the reviewers that their opinion was the same as the other reviewer, emphasizing the quality of the reviewer.
This second point is unusual, but some journals do.
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
看不到的
Yes, the reviewers cannot see each other's comments. But there are some exceptions.
1. Open review. Here everyone, including the authors and readers can see everything.
2. AFTER REJECTION by the office. I am an expert reviewer and occasionally a journal sends me what other reviewers said, but only after they rejected the manuscript. Why?. This is because it tells the reviewers that their opinion was the same as the other reviewer, emphasizing the quality of the reviewer.
This second point is unusual, but some journals do.
，
肯定看不到啊，都是独立的