各位虫友，麻烦过来看一下
我的一篇文章在5个月前投到一影响因子为2.0的期刊（本领域算不低的了），被主编直接以英语太烂拒掉。之后修四个月，期间请三位国外友人（美国人一个，在美中国人两个）看过，我还是坚持尝试，一个月前再投，现在结果是reject and resubmit（真不清楚这是啥决定）。主编回信如下：
In view of the comments of the referees, I must decline the manuscript for publication in **** at this time.  However, a new manuscript may be submitted which takes into consideration these comments.  In the previous version of this manuscript the editor had commented on obscure expressions and written language.  The reviewers of the present manuscript raise similar issues.  If you wish to resubmit your manuscript, please be sure to respond to the comments of the reviewers in full.  Regarding the language usage, you may wish to use an English language checking service, such as those listed on the Wiley web site。。。
Please note that resubmitting your manuscript does not guarantee eventual acceptance, and that your resubmission will be subject to re-review before a decision is rendered.
附一个审稿人意见：
This paper revisits a well-known problem in the modeling of **, that of obtaining accurate and non-oscillatory solutions for coupled hydro-mechanical problems, the difficulty being that the order of the displacement solution has to be greater than that for the pore water pressure. The use of the ** is innovative and a positive feature of this work.
另一个审稿人意见：

in the present paper, the ** technique is stabilized by using less points for the pressure approximation than for the displacements. This, essentially, causes the pressure to be approximated with low accuracy than the displacement. Hence, it follows the same idea as Taylor-Hood-elements in a FEM formulation. Surprisingly, the use of different ansatz orders like for Taylor-Hood elemtns does not work for the **. There is no mathematical proof but two studies which show that the idea work. Unfortunately, the essential question what must be the relation between the amount of nodes for the displacement and the pressure approximation is not answered.（帮忙看看这个审稿人是支持还是反对）
其实那两个审稿人提的问题没有特别尖锐的问题，一般是些词语不当之类。
由于作者就是我一个人，在此领域又是第一次，大家有没有这种经验的？感觉好艰难啊，有如此经历的说说看。。。。谢谢。

[ Last edited by hualeina on 2010-6-22 at 10:33 ] 返回小木虫查看更多