请教这个算是大修还是小修？
博士的第一篇文章投到ISME J 审稿2月后给revision。3个审稿人 两个评价比较好 还有个没评价好坏 只提了几个问题。 编辑回信如下，请问各位这个算是minor 还是 major revision? 谢谢各位
Thank you for submitting your manuscript to The ISME Journal. Your manuscript was reviewed by several experts in the field; and we are enclosing the comments they have made. As you can see, the reviewers think that the work is of potential interest; however, significant concerns have also been voiced, which would preclude publication of the paper in its present form.
We are willing to consider a revised version of the manuscript providing that you satisfy the criticisms raised in the attached comments by the reviewers and/or the Editors. The manuscript requires a thorough revision and as you can see from the comments that most points raised are straight forward to consider. I would agree with referees #1 and #3 that you need to make the effort to better explain the methods and reasoning behind your experimental/cultivation design and consider related studies. Please also comment on the origin of the strain.
Generally, a revised manuscript should be re-submitted within 1 month. Additional time for revision may be granted to the authors upon request. Please inform the editorial office immediately if you anticipate need for such an extension.
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
� a thorough revision” 从这里看你应该是大修。
另外ISME J上对审稿人的要求可以看出
Manuscripts that are sent for formal review typically go to multiple referees. Based on their advice, the editor decides to:
1、accept the manuscript, with or without minor revision
2、invite the authors to revise the manuscript to address specific concerns before a final decision is reached
3、reject the manuscript, typically on grounds of specialist interest, lack of novelty, insufficient conceptual advance or major technical and/or interpretational problems.
明显编辑回复中提到We are willing to consider a revised version of the manuscript providing that you satisfy the criticisms raised in the attached comments by the reviewers and/or the Editors. 所以就是对应第二条大修 而非第一条小修。但是大修1个月时间上有点短，不补充大实验的话，倒也还可以。加油，祝你成功，
大修，不过不管大修小修都要认真修改。一般都不会有问题的。
大修修改得好，录用可能性很高；小修修改得不到位，也会被拒。所以好好修改是根本
按照他的意思应该是大修
说上去是大修，但算不上大修，大修revise的时间段应该是2-3个月，但是楼主的只是一个月，认真修改相信一定是好的结果