24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

eagles123

金虫 (正式写手)

MicEPI: 1
应助: 154 (高中生)
金币: 5854.4
散金: 1607
红花: 12
帖子: 667
在线: 700.7小时
虫号: 322286
注册: 2007-03-11
性别: GG
专业: 环境微生物学

[求助] 请教这个算是大修还是小修？已有1人参与

博士的第一篇文章投到ISME J 审稿2月后给revision。3个审稿人两个评价比较好还有个没评价好坏只提了几个问题。编辑回信如下，请问各位这个算是minor 还是 major revision? 谢谢各位

Thank you for submitting your manuscript to The ISME Journal. Your manuscript was reviewed by several experts in the field; and we are enclosing the comments they have made. As you can see, the reviewers think that the work is of potential interest; however, significant concerns have also been voiced, which would preclude publication of the paper in its present form.

We are willing to consider a revised version of the manuscript providing that you satisfy the criticisms raised in the attached comments by the reviewers and/or the Editors. The manuscript requires a thorough revision and as you can see from the comments that most points raised are straight forward to consider. I would agree with referees #1 and #3 that you need to make the effort to better explain the methods and reasoning behind your experimental/cultivation design and consider related studies. Please also comment on the origin of the strain.
Generally, a revised manuscript should be re-submitted within 1 month. Additional time for revision may be granted to the authors upon request. Please inform the editorial office immediately if you anticipate need for such an extension.

回复此楼

» 猜你喜欢

Bioresource Technology期刊，第一次返修的时候被退回好几次了已经有6人回复
2025冷门绝学什么时候出结果已经有4人回复
真诚求助：手里的省社科项目结项要求主持人一篇中文核心，有什么渠道能发核心吗已经有8人回复
寻求一种能扛住强氧化性腐蚀性的容器密封件已经有5人回复
论文投稿，期刊推荐已经有6人回复
请问哪里可以有青B申请的本子可以借鉴一下。已经有4人回复
孩子确诊有中度注意力缺陷已经有14人回复
请问下大家为什么这个铃木偶联几乎不反应呢已经有5人回复
请问有评职称，把科研教学业绩算分排序的高校吗已经有5人回复
天津工业大学郑柳春团队欢迎化学化工、高分子化学或有机合成方向的博士生和硕士生加入已经有4人回复

» 本主题相关价值贴推荐，对您同样有帮助:

请教---- 论文大修后还有可能被拒吗？？？已经有32人回复
chemical communications小修，审稿人意见请教已经有8人回复
调查一下IEEE Trans的论文修改后（包括大修小修），几天接受的啊？已经有7人回复
犯了很多低级错误，评审意见为大修，求教发表的可能性已经有17人回复
第一次做国外期刊审稿人，想请教前辈们大修小修如何界定？已经有15人回复
论文修改第二次了，也没有写大修还是小修，都是revise，第二次修改都半个月还没消息已经有12人回复
一年后收到初审意见没标明大修还是小修已经有9人回复
紧急求助:Energy srouces 一次大修，一次小修后拒稿，能够给主编写信说明情况已经有20人回复
Electrochimica Acta 二审编辑的回信没有说大修小修已经有40人回复
审稿意见：一个大修，两个小修已经有34人回复
我的第一SCI投稿返回意见了，这个算大修还是小修？ Physica A 已经有11人回复
PRB这样的审稿意见算是大修还是小修？已经有6人回复
这属于大修还是小修？已经有37人回复
大家帮我看看，我这种情况属于大修还是小修？已经有3人回复
第一篇SCI接受的曲折过程：2次大修+1次小修+4次送审。已经有223人回复
请看下这个是大修还是小修已经有18人回复
小修或者大修一般多久给消息？已经有6人回复
ChemComm从小修变成大修－悲哀阿，痛心阿，百感交集已经有18人回复
这属于大修还是小修？已经有18人回复
文章给修改，遇到点问题，不知道怎么回答，向版上的兄弟姐妹请教！！已经有7人回复
小修变大修，大哭一场！该怎么办？已经有82人回复
帮我看看啊:编辑是要大修还是小修？已经有15人回复
大修之后的小修，怎么办呢？已经有11人回复
投稿MSE-C请教各位虫友，小修还会返回给审稿人吗已经有17人回复

1楼2013-03-10 10:10:39

已阅回复此楼关注TA 给TA发消息送TA红花 TA的回帖

kydarling

铜虫 (正式写手)

应助: 5 (幼儿园)
金币: 32068.6
红花: 3
帖子: 946
在线: 199.8小时
虫号: 442320
注册: 2007-10-27
性别: GG
专业: 环境微生物学

【答案】应助回帖

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★
感谢参与，应助指数 +1
eagles123: 金币+5, ★★★很有帮助 2013-03-11 13:41:01
laozuzunzhe: 金币+3, good! 2013-03-11 14:21:33

“ a thorough revision” 从这里看你应该是大修。

另外ISME J上对审稿人的要求可以看出
Manuscripts that are sent for formal review typically go to multiple referees. Based on their advice, the editor decides to:
1、accept the manuscript, with or without minor revision
2、invite the authors to revise the manuscript to address specific concerns before a final decision is reached
3、reject the manuscript, typically on grounds of specialist interest, lack of novelty, insufficient conceptual advance or major technical and/or interpretational problems.

明显编辑回复中提到We are willing to consider a revised version of the manuscript providing that you satisfy the criticisms raised in the attached comments by the reviewers and/or the Editors. 所以就是对应第二条大修而非第一条小修。但是大修1个月时间上有点短，不补充大实验的话，倒也还可以。加油，祝你成功！