文章被编辑拒稿,审稿人一个revised,一个 publish,还可以argue吗
最近投稿,审稿人没有明确拒绝,编辑给拒稿了,还可以argue吗?
编辑意见:.....After careful evaluation of the manuscript and reviewers’ comments, I regret to inform you that we do not find your manuscript suitable for publication and therefore it has been rejected from XXX......
审稿人1:....... However, this manuscript needs to be totally revised and well organized......
审稿人2: .......Therefore, I believe that the paper is convincing and worth to be published in XXX.......
两个审稿人提出的问题也不是很难,编辑拒稿了,我还可以argue一下吗?
返回小木虫查看更多
今日热帖
京公网安备 11010802022153号
试试呗,反正不费多少事
9
这样的审稿意见不应该是给修改的意见吗?怎么能拒稿呢,什么杂志这么傲娇。
必中
盲猜wiely下面的杂志
说不准,有可能第一个在出版意见中选的是not publish。可以申述一下,不过除非很明显的判断错误,不然希望不大
,