International Journal of Biological Macromolecules特刊的三年多审稿的反思
2017年1月3日投稿international journal of biological macromolecules ijbiomac-d-17-00001r2历经两次修改,在华人编辑的帮助下终于给了拒稿的通知:ms. ref. no.: ijbiomac-d-17-00001r2
title: retrogradation of sweet potato amylose and amylopectin with narrow molecular weight distribution
international journal of biological macromolecules
dear dr.
reviewers' comments on your work have now been received. you will see that they are advising against publication of your work. therefore i must reject it.
for your guidance, i append the reviewers' comments below.
thank you for giving us the opportunity to consider your work.
special issue guest editor: unfortunately, after two times revision there are still some problem leading the paper to major revision. hence, this paper is not enough for publishing yet.
thanks for your patience and understanding.
稿件转给特刊没有经过作者同意,特刊文章周期真的太长了,这篇文章写的什么我都差不多忘记了,期间催稿无数次,伊朗的一个责任编辑根本不搭理,好像已经换掉了,我们做科研的能等得起多少个3年呀。前车之鉴,供大家参考借鉴。
[ last edited by lianxijun2007 on 2020-3-21 at 22:29 ]
[ Last edited by lianxijun2007 on 2020-3-23 at 14:23 ]
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
我也有片大修,哎,这么严格,我还以为是水刊
坑死人啊
棒棒哒
三年,太夸张了
最担心的是编辑本身就想否定此文,一次次审稿没有否定意见,会不停送外审直至有了自认为满意的否定意见,然后拒稿,这篇文章最后只有一个第七审稿人建议大修,并未说拒稿。我的是特刊,正刊通常没这种情况,我以前在此刊发了不少文章,大多数编辑还是不错的,这次可能是个例外,希望您好运
,
特别想呼吁国家科技部、教育部:想方设法多开办我们自己的高水平外文期刊,提高我们国家自己期刊社的水平,限制科研人员不要再给国外期刊交版面费杂志投稿了,只要选择国际高水平评委审稿,没有办不好的杂志。
换个杂志投,说不定投个影响因子高的反而中了。你以前在此刊发了不少文章,说明还是很有水平的。