Reviewer #1: The topic is interesting and novel and the paper seems very complete concerning the number/quality of experimental tests performed to characterize the material. The work has potential for possible publication but the following aspects deserve answer/clarification:

Reviewer #2:  This article continues the series of author′s scientific work focused on the halloysite.
The characteristics of the used halloysite and experimental methods are described in detail in the introduction of the experimental chapter.
The results of individual measurements are described in detail, and they are discussed extensively at the end of the experimental chapter.
There are no serious errors in the article. Recommendation: Publish after revision according to Comments to authors.


二审被拒的概率大不大 返回小木虫查看更多