review after Revision,还有没有希望?
3个月给一审意见,一共12条,发现全是问题,咋个改啊?
reviewer1:
There are some comments as follows.
1. For better readability, authors should introduce the status and motivation of this work, and summarize with a paragraph about this paper.
2. Equations should end with a comma or a period depending on their position within a sentence and denote with equation number.
3. Please enhance reasonable analyses and discussions for experimental results.
4. The article should present the limitations of the work and directions for future research in the conclusion, which means the conclusions section should be further enhanced.
5. Please ensure that the references are correct and in compliance with the ###'s style.
reviewer2:
The detailed comments are as follows.
1. Please prepare and revise the manuscript according to the paper template of ###.
2. The paper writing needs to be improved and polished. There are some sentences that are grammatically incorrect and too long to comprehend. The authors should ask a native English spoken person to proof read the manuscript.
3. The authors should compare the proposed work to other relevant works in detail. There is a need for this manuscript to differentiate itself from the related works.
4. In order to point out the technical contribution of the paper, please summarize the technical achievements of this work in the Introduction section.
5. For better readability and comprehensibility, please highlight the key research problem of this work clearly.
6. All of equations should end with a comma or period according to their position within a sentence. Please recheck them completely.
7. Please ensure that all references in the Reference list are in compliance the reference format of ### and are cited in the text and vice versa.
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
其实12个建议修改问题已经很正常了
有如影响因子越高的期刊一般在20个建议修改,或者更多
光是回复修改答复 就达几十页
今年2区论文 回复写了慢慢22页答复 可想而之 有多变态
没办法 需要仔细的 认真的 一一回复
所以12个真的 在正常不过了
慢慢来
祝好
这是中国人审的吧?
其实很好改吧,而且你的问题都不是很难去回答,只要认真修改回答每一个问题,审稿人都不会有太大的意见,主要就是要看你是否尊重审稿人的意见
挺好的,好好修改,祝好运
看样子很有机会啊,主要就是写作表达上的问题以及加些对比方法。
这种comments一般来讲已经非常nice了,而且comments确实不多,好好修改,机会很大!
我跟上边各位回复的想法是一样的。你的这些建议算是轻松的了,基本都是语言和写作的问题。
前几天在丁香园上看到有人说找润色机构觉得不光彩,今天就借你的帖子说一下我的想法:如果经费允许的话,自己先把reviewer提出来的建议一句一句的修改了,然后找个润色公司把自己的文章polish一下,绝对值得~不光对自己有益,对所有人都有益!
,
加油!
我改过几十条意见