两个审稿人同意接受,一个不同意,希望大么
I now have three reviews of your paper submission. ?Copies of reviewers comemnts are attached. ?Reviewers #1 and 2 are for publication after revisions are made in response to their comments. ?Reviewer #3 is against publication. ?Please revise you paper in response to reviewers comments and return the revised paper to me. ?Also include a list of reviewers comments, along with your response to each comment and the revisions made in response to each comment. ?I will then send the revised paper to reviewer #3 for review before deciding on publication.
返回小木虫查看更多
今日热帖
京公网安备 11010802022153号
这是明显想要的节奏啊。好好改,不过如果第三个审稿人还不同意就麻烦了。加油!
祝好,好好修改
应该没问题 认真写一下response letter 祝好运!
这种情况一般编辑会尊重多数意见,但是会要求按照所有审稿人的意见修改。如果要求拒稿的提出修改意见,你就也照着改。但是如果他一味要求拒稿,没有任何具体建议,更好办。只需要态度诚恳的说明为什么本稿件意义重大,主要是让编辑信服就行了
,
很大!
希望很大!
希望不大