论文被拒了,下面的情况可以申诉吗?
最近一篇文章投的GRSL,先是reject & resubmit ,然后 Major Revision,今天收到的消息是reject。两个审稿人意见,一个是acceptance 一个是reject。
Reviewer: 1
Comments to the Author
Unfortunately, the authors still did not convince me on the practical utilization of the methodology. The authors mention that the work is done, but it could not be reported here, as this is a letter. I think this is not a scientific justification. If it is not possible as a letter, you can improve the article and submit it to JSTARS. In the end, we need to have a scientifically convincing processing chain along with significant validation to show the utility of the proposed method.
Reviewer: 2
Comments to the Author
Generally, the authors have addressed most of my previous comments carefully. The manuscript is suggested to be accepted now.
审稿人1 拒稿的理由说到已经有做过我的工作,这个我没看到谁做过。他让我补充内容投一个更好的期刊JSTARS。
大家说说,我还可以申诉吗?申诉有机会吗?
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
每一个人收到reject的时候都是不甘心的。习惯了麻木了就好了。
appeal本来就是个小概率事件。看命了~~Good Luck
你是给谁写信呢?AE吗?
就是自己拒稿的那个邮件,回复吗?
我记得我那阵大修之后,也是一个同样发表一个说创新性不高,所以最后给拒了。其实吧,这样的事情,习惯了就好了,楼主加油,在投个其他的
谢谢您的回复,但是我这个也没有说我创新性问题,如果是说我创新性有问题,我也就算了
,
我已经申诉结束,坚持原判。哎, 只有扩充了重写。