Industrial crops and products 投稿,总是退回来说有问题,搞不清楚编辑是什么意思?
投稿Industrial crops and products, 状态with editor下3个月,终于来了意见。结果意见是:
Dear Dr. ***,
Thank you for submitting the above-mentioned article to Industrial Crops and Products.
Unfortunately, we cannot pass on your manuscript to peer reviewers, since the following items are missing:
1. Log into the Elsevier Editorial System for Industrial Crops and Products as an Author:https://ees.elsevier.com/
Your username is: *****
2. Locate INDCRO-D-16-01*** in your 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder.
3. Check the "File Inventory" to ensure that all of the required items are included:
*Highlights (where applicable)
Highlights are mandatory. They consist of a short collection of bullet points that convey the core findings of the article and should be submitted in a separate file in the online submission system. Please use 'Highlights' in the file name and include 3 to 5 bullet points (maximum 85 characters, including spaces, per bullet point). See https://www.elsevier.com/highlights for examples.
4. Submit your revised paper by clicking 'Submit Revision' and completing the submission steps.
Note: Be sure to include a separate document uploaded as "Response to Reviewers" that carefully addresses, point-by-point, the issues raised in this letter (i.e. "My paper now includes Highlights and source files." ).
We once again thank you for your contribution to Industrial Crops and Products and look forward to publishing your work.
由于第一次投时,我没有写highlights。我修改加上highlights,然后再提交。过几天,结果又回来了,意见跟上面一次是完全是一样。我以为格式问题,再修改,再提交。过几天,编辑回复的意见还是跟原来一模一样。后来,我发现我的highlights有个句子超过85个字符,然后我再修改至少于85个字符。再提交,结果几天后的回复意见还是一样。
反复总共4次,修改意见还是一样。那么是什么原因呢?编辑的意思是什么呢?我的highlights写得不够core?
注:我的highlight总共有4个句子,每个句子都不超过85个字符。
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
Highlights是否是单独一个文件?
"Response to Reviewers" 是否是point-by-point?
好好读读投稿指南。
highlights 是单独一个文件上传的。
response to reviewers 文件,由于email只有一个issue,就没有一条一条(point by point)的解答吧。response to reviewers 文件我就写了一句话“My paper now includes Highlights and source files.”
,
也准备投这个杂志那,不知道接不接收三萜皂苷了类的成分,犹豫中。。。
最新消息
我在投稿页面的写了个email,质问了一番。
然后把相同的email发给负责的编辑。
几天内没有答复。
然后,我再对highlight内容修改了一下,再投,变了R4版本。
终于有答复了,说可以送同行评审。但是,编辑换了一个人。
唉,究竟是编辑人员问题还是我的highlight问题,这个问题最终还是没有答案。
请问楼主最后解决了吗?我现在收到的revision邮件和你一样 不知道怎么改?