TIE审稿意见求分析
新人所有金币都散出去
两个月前重新投的IEEE TIE,昨天给的大修结果,感觉评审意见挺狠的,这样能让大修已经不错了。
现在难点是我文章已经八页了(TIE规定页书),他们给了很多条评审意见,我要都加进去肯定超篇幅了,请前辈们指教怎么办,再投的话中的概率大吗?以下是审稿意见
Keio University, Yokohama, Japan, 04-Aug-2016
Dear Authors,
The review process of your manuscript No. 16-TIE-1627 entitled "Implant Position of Receiving Coils of the Wireless Charging System for the Implantable Cardiac Pacemaker" as a Regular paper submission, has been completed.
Based on the opinions of the reviewers and the Associate Editor in charge, your manuscript requires a major revision.
- Please revise your manuscript within 6 weeks to address the enclosed reviewers' comments, and highlight the changes in the manuscript. Your revised manuscript will be evaluated again.
- Please understand that the manuscript is still considered to be in the review process, so it is important that authors' names and affiliations must NOT be identifiable in any documents uploaded to Manuscript Central. Otherwise the paper will be automatically rejected.
Please note that if your revised manuscript exceeds the page limit of TIE (3 pages for "Letter to Editor" and 8 pages for regular and "Special Section" papers), extra page cost will be billed to you, according to the rate posted by IEEE. The manuscript length couldn't exceed 10 pages (5 pages for letters).
Your kind cooperation is greatly appreciated.
Sincerely yours,
Prof. Kouhei Ohnishi
Editor-in-Chief
IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
祝福
倒数第二个比较狠
没有很尖锐的意见,注意回答review1 的第三个问题和review3的问题,这种问题是AE比较在意的,会影响到最终的结果。其他的该补做实验补实验,文章语法错误改一遍,没啥问题,祝好!
作者指南要求文章篇幅限制在8页针对初稿,修改稿超过8页没有关系。一般给了编辑大修的机会,就说明存在修改稿被接收的可能。如果楼主能够完全领会审稿人的意图,回答令人满意,修改到位,文章就能顺利被接收,