仅仅是改语言那么简单吗?
前后耗时近一年,首篇SCI终于有结果了,可现在仅仅是修改语言那么简单吗?
第一次投完后近3个月,给了大修意见,我严格按照审稿人和编辑的要求修改,回复了近10页。
又等了快80天,终于有了结果,Acceptable after minor revision
编辑的回复是这样的:
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX (题目)
XXXXXX (杂志名)
Dear XXXX,
I can now inform you that the two former Reviewers have once again evaluated the manuscript XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX (题目名称).
I am pleased to inform you that it has been favourably received by the reviewers. However, the language was not suffciently corrected and needs further improvement by a native speaker. Several sentences are not clear and syntax incorrect. Moreover, please check also the abstract again and add missing information, such as what are (Line 23) "XXXXXXXXXX"? XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX(Line 24)? XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXx(Line 25)?
这段后面我明白什么意思(改摘要+几个问题),前面说语句表达不清+语法错误,编辑真是这个意思吗?看到有人说小修后也有可能拒稿,心里有点怕怕的。
Thus, you are advised that the manuscript will be acceptable subject to satisfactory minor revision.
这句的意思,我的理解是改到满意为止?
The comments above and below should be taken into account when revising the manuscript. You do not need to provide a detailed covering letter in which you list all the changes you have made to the manuscript.
However, please, colour your changes in the revised manuscript or use "track changes" that reviewers and editors can immediately recognize where the changes have been made.
有没有类似投稿经验的虫友啊?????
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
你不满意吗? 一定要让你再多改几次?
审稿人复审时其实很松的,你按他的要求改了,回答也到位了,
很多时候就是一句话说可以接受,就算是复审意见了,恭喜兄弟!
找个英语母语的人帮助修改好语言,就会录用;否则也有被拒的可能。
好好修改语言,机率很大
楼主正解,审稿专家认为语言润色不到位,细节决定成败,如果找不到英语为母语的专家帮忙把关,就只能请润色公司了,一定要修改到让审稿专家和编辑都满意才行。
谢谢谢谢,希望如此吧,已经自己先改了
,
谢谢,我也很想找一个英语母语的人改,可我们单位没有这样的人,润色的话,费用不知该怎么出
谢谢,借你吉言。。。。。