当前位置: 首页 > 论文投稿 >都没送审被编辑拒了(journal of service research),从拒信里能看出点啥门道么?

都没送审被编辑拒了(journal of service research),从拒信里能看出点啥门道么?

作者 yangyan_kid
来源: 小木虫 350 7 举报帖子
+关注

拒信如下,感觉特别对不起教授。。。连审稿人那边都没推到,哎~越看越难受。。。
感觉好像是因为contributions不强被拒的,教授当时做实验设计的时候就提出过,但还是放手让我做了。

Dear XXX:
Thank you for submitting your manuscript, "xxxxxxxx” to the Journal of Service Research.
I have read your paper with respect to its potential suitability for JSR.
Unfortunately, after considering the manuscript, I have concluded that the paper is
not positioned well for JSR’s focus nor does it rise to JSR’s current standards for
academic contribution to service research.

The JSR is a scholarly journal that publishes the highest level of research relating
to service. To be published in JSR, a manuscript must significantly advance
theory, provide managerially-meaningful and generalizable empirical research, or
provide new models or methods that can be used to improve service.
Unfortunately, your paper does not match this profile.

The paper is very interesting, the research is well-designed, and the analyses
appear to be carefully done and sophisticated. The paper is also very well written.
While these are clear strengths of the research, the focus on XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX, is not a good fit with
JSR. The paper is purely focused on e-retailing and product issues and,
unfortunately, the potential contributions to service theory and practice are not
apparent. Research published in JSR must be anchored in academic service
research and directly applicable to service theory and practice. Based on its focus
and the vast majority of the references included in the paper, it seems the paper is
a much better fit for a pure marketing, retailing or consumer behavior journal.
Thus, despite its strengths, I am sorry that I must reject your paper.

Thank you for thinking of JSR for your research and I hope you will consider the
journal again when you have research that is a bit more general and tied directly to
service.

Best wishes for success with your research program 返回小木虫查看更多

今日热帖
  • 精华评论
  • qtech_he

    都是套话,就说你的论文主题与期刊主题不符,请另投他刊。

  • yangyan_kid

    引用回帖:
    2楼: Originally posted by qtech_he at 2016-02-16 06:20:19
    都是套话,就说你的论文主题与期刊主题不符,请另投他刊。

    第一次收到类似拒信,所以不太懂。所以没有实质上对文章的评价什么的?单单是题材问题?

  • yangyan_kid

    引用回帖:
    2楼: Originally posted by qtech_he at 2016-02-16 06:20:19
    都是套话,就说你的论文主题与期刊主题不符,请另投他刊。

    所以不涉及到对文章质量的评价?还是怎么的?我现在不确定文章只是题材问题还是质量问题,第一次遇到这种编辑拒的,不太清楚

  • qtech_he

    跟文章质量没关系,找一个题材相像的期刊投。过了编辑就可以,进行内容评估了

  • dorischow

    因为跟JSR主题不是很符合,因此,他们并未深入你文章具体研究内容来评价。倒可以再研究下是否有主题更合适的期刊,这样reviewer也容易找到。另外,他提出你参考文献很多,保罗了很多领域,很难归为具体某个主题的期刊。这一点可能你下次再投时也要考虑一下。

  • yangyan_kid

    引用回帖:
    6楼: Originally posted by dorischow at 2016-02-16 06:52:49
    因为跟JSR主题不是很符合,因此,他们并未深入你文章具体研究内容来评价。倒可以再研究下是否有主题更合适的期刊,这样reviewer也容易找到。另外,他提出你参考文献很多,保罗了很多领域,很难归为具体某个主题的期 ...

    嗯,有道理,我这文章确实有点难归类有点交叉型。教授回邮件说确实文章和service不太相关,被拒也正常,好在非常快,可以改投别的

猜你喜欢
下载小木虫APP
与700万科研达人随时交流
  • 二维码
  • IOS
  • 安卓