IEEE论文被拒,修改后重投,主编说我投稿方式不对,求助大家帮忙看看
IEEE论文被拒后,我写了回稿意见后重新带编号投,主编说我投稿方式不对,不符合IEEE投稿标准。现贴出邮件,求助大家帮忙看看。问题解决后金币奉上,麻烦大家了。
This submission is linked to the rejected manuscript ***. Despite the fact that this latter paper was rejected without allowing for a resubmission, you submitted a new paper along with a protest.
This is not the correct formal procedure in any IEEE Transactions and certainly not in the IEEE Trans. on Control Systems Technology.
The formal procedure is the following:
- you send a protest along with a rebuttal by email to the Editor in Chief
- the protest will be evaluated with the help of the reviewers, the AE and possibly an independent member of the Board
- in case the protest will make a case for reconsidering the previous rejection decision, such a decision will be rescinded and a revised submission will be allowed according to some conditions
- instead, in case the protest will not lead to reconsider the previous rejection decision, such a decision will be confirmed and no revised manuscript will be considered for review.
Therefore, the present manuscript is rejected without review.
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
换个期刊吧。何必为难自己也为难编辑。
这写得不是清清楚楚么
邮件回复,你当时的论文是reject without allowing for a resubmission,现在你把这论文进行重投,违背了原始的decision。
如果需要重投,需要先给EiC写rebuttal,然后他们同意后才可以resubmission
你做revision之前,难道都不看decision是大小改或者能不能重投的么。。。。
IEEE的不好中,换期刊吧下次写的好一些再投。
因为之前是被拒且不允许重投
如果你仍想修改后重投
必须向主编申述并说明理由
由主编决定是否同意你重投
退稿信件写的很清楚啦,不要再投这个杂志啦,早点改投,为自己节省点时间吧,不要做无用功。
老板看过审稿意见,觉得没有太难回答的问题,所以就写回稿了,之前没遇到过这种情况,只能说以后遇到这样的问题会先了解清楚的
,
只能这样了