当前位置: 首页 > 论文投稿 >一审回来的结果为什么还是revise

一审回来的结果为什么还是revise

作者 kevin21
来源: 小木虫 2050 41 举报帖子
+关注

求教下大家这个一审后的结果是怎么回事?一审给的是Revise,二审还是revise,没有major和minor之分么?
Reviewer #1: I am happy that authors have considered all the comments in a positive way and have modified the manuscript accordingly. The manuscript is now OK for me.

just suggest authors carefully check English presentation of this paper. Ask a professional to proofread if possible.

Reviewer #2: The adopted method is simple and interesting. (中间是对论文的概述)The research is significant since it studies real dataset, and the results are valid. It has rarely been done before; it is more effective compared with previous similar models; and its effectiveness has been examined according to certain criteria.
Also suggest authors cite 1-2 related papers published in the KBS journal in 2015. 返回小木虫查看更多

今日热帖
  • 精华评论
  • 亚楠

    明天问题很好解决了,应该是小修,好好改,祝好运!

  • wuyuye

    有的期刊不分major和minor,就是revise,放心吧,只要让你修,按要求认真改,肯定能中的!
    祝福楼主好运~,

  • eriophyoid

    给翻译公司看看。然后文献可引可不引的。

  • songyafei

    请问楼主,这篇文章是哪个主编负责的?

  • samsonov

    好好修改细节,问题不大了

  • XDxiaohu

    估计马上就要接收了,祝好

  • 叶回

    我一个师兄投的一个期刊,minor给了两个月的修改时间,我的major给的28天,应该跟时间无关。

猜你喜欢
下载小木虫APP
与700万科研达人随时交流
  • 二维码
  • IOS
  • 安卓