On the basis of the review(s) appended below, we regret that your manuscript cannot be accepted in its present form for publication in ACA. However, it is the opinion of the Editor that there is potential merit in the work described and that a thorough consideration of the reviewer comments might result in a publishable paper. We would therefore be willing to consider a new manuscript that describes this work. Since this will be considered as a new submittal, it can be submitted online at any future time. In such a case, in the cover letter please address the prior comments of the reviewers, detailing what changes have been made.

这种情况下，重投的编辑reviewer会是原来的审稿人吗？自己网上查了下，也是众说纷纭。我觉得基本上原来的comments都被我用实验或者数据解释了，如果换审稿人，再提一堆其他意见，也挺危险的。而且根据现有reviewer意见的改动，新的reviewer未必关注这点。纠结！ 返回小木虫查看更多