这样的编辑回信能否补充实验数据再投这个杂志
主编分配的副主编,副主编没有送审,说我文章的测定温度范围没有40度,我做了一个混合体系6种配比,22-60度38度范围。应该就是实验数据不够,不能发表,叫我另外投别的杂志。我能不能补充了数据点以后重新计算再投这个杂志,以下是编辑来信:
Thank you for considering the Journal of Chemical & Engineering Data for your manuscript submission. The Journal of Chemical & Engineering Data is committed to promoting high standards in the fields that it covers.
After reviewing your manuscript, I have concluded that it contains insufficient data (the solubility of at least 1 solute in at least 4 different solvent mixtures, or of at least 4 solutes in 1 solvent mixture over a temperature range of at least 40 K is required). I regret any inconvenience, but I hope that this prompt return will allow you to consider alternative journals without further delay. Our Scope and Editorial Policy are available at https://pubs.acs.org/paragonplus ... x/jceaax_scope.pdf.
谢谢大家
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
应该是不行了,你的实验数据缺失不怎么多,不同溶剂摩尔分率下的不同温度点,你可以数数一共有几个。
少于50个点的话缺失不够。
不过也有可能是编辑觉得您的文章有其他问题,没有指出。
化工热力学数据这个杂志最近严格了很多,