06-jun-2021


manuscript id pel-2021-02-0062.r1 entitled "adaptive control strategy of solid state transformer for fast dynamic response and excellent balance performance" submitted to iet power electronics has been reviewed. please see below for editor and reviewers comments. we look forward to receiving the revised version of your paper.

editor-in-chief comments:

we appreciate the efforts and time invested by the authors to improve their manuscript. however, reviewers still not satisfied with the response and identified some areas of concerns. we would like to give authors a final opportunity to fully address these comments and concerns. please note that the next decision will be either accept or reject, hence we encourage you to take them seriously.

associate editor comments to author:

associate editor
comments to the author:
dear authors,

please consider the comments of the reviewers. mainly those related to the critical problems that were not addressed in the manuscript. also, consider adding novel references to your paper. both reviewers indicate that your paper is poor at that point.

reviewer(s)' comments to author:

reviewer: 2

comments to the author
thanks for the authors’ response. some good improvements have been made, but some critical problems are not addressed clearly in the revised manuscript.
1) the author replied the reviewers’ comments one-by-one. however not all corresponding modifications have been made.
2) as stated in the response letter, the voltage balance and power balance have been achieved well in the actual 10-kv sst prototypes. why the proposed strategy is required?
3) for the single-phase ac-dc sst (single-phase chb), is the eq. (1) ok? check ref.

[ Last edited by 够不着的蓝 on 2021-6-7 at 10:13 ] 返回小木虫查看更多