Required Reviews Completed变了日期,而且发了两封邮件?
第一次遇到这样的事情。这个杂志,当从“under review”变成“Required Reviews Completed”是要发邮件的。
一审的时候到这个状态,大概一周多,就收到decision了。三个外审,一个直接收,两个只是说图不太清楚,格式问题等。不难改。
目前是二审,本周一收到邮件,变成“Required Reviews Completed”了,就等结果。然后到了昨天,居然收到第二封邮件,和第一封一摸一样,说状态变成“Required Reviews Completed”了。然后进去看了一下,上次状态的日期是11日,现在变成了16日。其他一切都没变。不知道发生了什么事情?以前从未遇到这种情况。
大家有何经验,这是怎么回事?
附上状态变化时杂志社系统发的邮件(11日和16日收到了两次,一字未变):
I am pleased to inform you that the status of your submission has now progressed to: 'Required reviews complete'.
This status means that I have received the minimum number of required reviews, which I will now evaluate in order to make a decision on your paper.
If the current reviews conflict with one another or are not detailed enough, I may need to seek the opinion of another reviewer to make a fair and informed conclusion about your paper. For this reason the status of your paper may change back to 'under review' for a short period of time.
As soon as the final editor's decision can be made, you will be notified via email.
I appreciate your understanding of the time required to provide you with a thorough decision and comments on your submission.
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
收到2个审稿意见发一封,后来第三个也回意见了,再发一封
审稿人意见回来了,编辑估计近期就会给你结果了
祝福
很多期刊设置 2 个审稿意见为缺省值,也就是最低审稿意见的要求。当返回 2 个审稿意见的时候,系统就变成 Required Reviews Completed 或 With Editor 状态,你的情况应该是编辑邀请了三个人,目前第三个已经返回,正等编辑作决定
一审的时候就没有这种情况,这封信只收到一次,然后回来三个意见
,
祝福
想知道楼主后来的进展如何呢??