当前位置: 首页 > 论文投稿 >decision letter 让转投其他期刊,是什么意思?后面还给列举了4点评论,建议大修

decision letter 让转投其他期刊,是什么意思?后面还给列举了4点评论,建议大修

作者 lijianghong
来源: 小木虫 600 12 举报帖子
+关注

Thank you for submitting your manuscript to European Polymer Journal.

After careful evaluation, and following reviewer assessment, I have determined there are other journals that may better suit your work.     

The alternative journals I recommend are listed here:  

Polymer Testing https://www.editorialmanager.com/POTE/

后面还给列举了4点评论,建议大修:
Editor and Reviewer Comments:    

Reviewer #1: 1.The manuscript needs proofread from a native English speaker.

2.The topic is too broad, but the manuscript is not correspondingly comprehensive enough, only hundred plus references. Take a simple example, papers from bioprinting-specific journals such as "Bioprinting" and "International Journal of Bioprinting" are limited, especially in recent 2 years.


3.On the other hand, the authors presented some of the latest development of biomaterials, more on ceramic and bioink but less on metal and polymer. However, it is unclear what points or insights they wish to provide. The current review is not critical enough, not indpeth, and very little has gone beyond current thinking in the field.


4.The authors should think clearly of the type of the review: comprehensive or in-depth? It is neither for the current manuscript. Since the topic of "latest development in 3D printing of biomaterials" is still interesting, a major revision is recommended.

      请教大神,这现在我是应该如何去做?进行大修还是同意转投呢? 返回小木虫查看更多

今日热帖
  • 精华评论
  • 叶落秋融

    按照意见好好修改,然后把修改后的文章,以及包含意见及回复的内容放在cover letter 里一起投到建议的期刊

  • ZL131210

    是这样的, 你同意转投的情况下,你也需要重新提交稿件,重新提交的稿件你可以修改也可以不修改,因为拒了,你完全可以觉得意见是不合理的,不改也正常。

  • 期待成长

    建议还是做适当修改,再重新投到将要转投的期刊,这是一个体系,一次次磨磨会使文章水平一步步的提升

  • lijianghong

    引用回帖:
    6楼: Originally posted by kmght at 2020-09-08 16:34:56
    审稿人虽然给了大修,但看来编辑给的转投吧?你也没法提交修改稿?

    是的,我就是这个意思,不过今天进去polymer testing的投稿系统,还是可以编辑投稿的

  • 英论阁cn

    大修并接受转投吧。编审很明确的指出可以改进的部分,相信仔细进行修改之后应该是没什么问题的。审稿人特别提到语言问题,国内作者在写英文论文时常会碍于语言表达被期刊拒稿,建议找有学科背景的英语母语编修公司帮你润色,内容很优秀但因为语言被拒就可惜了。

猜你喜欢
应助之星
下载小木虫APP
与700万科研达人随时交流
  • 二维码
  • IOS
  • 安卓