经过三轮审稿,审稿人已经没意见,但编辑给了这样的意见...是建议我转投吗?
文章已经审过三轮了,之前的审稿人意见基本都搞定了,最后编辑给我这样的意见,一方面建议我缩减图片数量,另一方面则是说我的文章更适合材料方向的期刊,可是我们在电化学学报已经发表过两篇类似研究内容的文章了,这篇可以说是前两篇的延伸研究。求教大家这个意见该怎么入手回答。
编辑意见:“thank you for submitting your revised manuscript. however, there are 17 figures. some of surface characterization figures such as xrd figures and sem images could be combined. some of them should be moved to the supporting info. your current manuscript seems to be more suitable for a material-oriented journal rather than electrochimica acta. if you are prepared to undertake the work required, i would be pleased to reconsider my decision. ”
返回小木虫查看更多
今日热帖
京公网安备 11010802022153号
是的,我最后按照编辑要求,把一些图进行了合并,一些放进了Supporting Information里,最后解释了这篇文章是前两篇我们已在本刊发表论文的延续研究,并对偏材料的分析讨论部分进行了一定的删减,希望能够顺利接受吧。谢谢你的建议
,