运多舛的小拙文,二审后with editor,过来人能否分析下中的几率大不大呢?(已录用)
本人投稿了一篇decision support systems,论文写了两年多,投稿持续近6个月了。下面是审稿流程,希望能有所帮助。
投稿流程如下:
2019/09/12 submitted;
2019/09/12 with editor;
2019/09/13 under review;
2019/10/13 under editor evaluation;
2019/11/29 revise;
2020/01/26 revision submitted to journal;
2020/02/10 required reviews completed;
2020/02/13 revise;
2020/03/03 With Editor;
2020/03/05 Under Review;
2020/03/09 revise;
2020/03/11 With Editor;
2020/03/11 Accept.
一审时:三位审稿人对论文评价比较积极,给出了一些修改意见,上面未显示大修还是小修,只是显示revision。
二审时:两位审稿人直接接受,一位审稿人直接拒绝(提的问题是细节性的问题)。但是主编还是给了修改的机会: though reviewer #2 recommended rejection, i have decided on one more r&r opportunity that needs to carefully and fully address the remaining concerns. good luck.
三审:第二位审稿人同意接受。
[ Last edited by dong3267435 on 2020-3-28 at 07:31 ]
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号