两个审稿人，一个拒稿，一个接收
投的surface and coatings technology，主编特意加了一段话:?It is unusual that a "major revision" is changed to a "reject" recommendation, but this is what reviewer 1 recommended. Now, I allow a further revision because reviewer 2 appreciated your work. At the same time, pay great attention to address all reviewer 1's criticisms, because they are major points. ?
返回小木虫查看更多
今日热帖
京公网安备 11010802022153号
祝好
认真修改。加油！祝福！
It is unusual that a "major revision" is changed to a "reject" recommendation
看样子是校正稿件时没能满足审稿人的要求
这种情况有时候会发生，两个审稿人的意见完全相反，这时候就看编辑怎么决定了。好事是编辑愿意给你修改的机会，这就行了。接下来就是按照编辑的要求，认真解决审稿人1的意见，当然还包括审稿人2，还是有希望的，加油，
审稿人1的问题佶屈聱牙，审稿人2没啥问题