求助,MDPI旗下论文被reject,但一直还没收到邮件
论文pending editor1天
under review 23天(7天的时候,有一个审稿人的意见返回来了,给的差差评)
然后昨天,23天的时候,我看系统,status是pending editor decision
点开view之后,里面有个editor decision,写的是:
Submission to First Decision (Days) 23
Editor Decision Decision Reject and decline resubmission
Decision Date 4 December 2019
Review Report Reviewer 1 Review Report (Round 1)
只有一个审稿人,给的审稿意见很差:
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
Although the implementation of the these kind of numerical models might be helpful for the fatigue analysis of such structures under study, the novelty by the authors is not given clearly.
In addition, the quality of presentation must be improved.
这种情况,我该怎么办呀?
想申诉一下,陈述一下自己的创新性,建议编辑再找两个审稿人,然后我推荐几个审稿人,然后再附上润色公司的润色证明。
各位觉得怎么样?谢谢大家了。
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
@songcumt 谢谢回复
够呛了,看看能不能修改吧,提升一下质量
review report form
english language and style
( ) extensive editing of english language and style required
(x) moderate english changes required
( ) english language and style are fine/minor spell check required
( ) i don't feel qualified to judge about the english language and style
does the introduction provide sufficient background and include all relevant references?
yes can be improved must be improved not applicable
( ) ( ) (x) ( )
is the research design appropriate?
yes can be improved must be improved not applicable
( ) ( ) (x) ( )
are the methods adequately described?
( ) ( ) (x) ( )
are the results clearly presented?
( ) ( ) (x) ( )
are the conclusions supported by the results?
( ) ( ) (x) ( )
comments and suggestions for authors
although the implementation of the these kind of numerical models might be helpful for the fatigue analysis of such structures under study, the novelty by the authors is not given clearly.
in addition, the quality of presentation must be improved.
submission date
11 november 2019
date of this review
18 nov 2019 23:09:55,
上面这是审稿意见。
明明是润色公司润色过的,非说英语不好,真是想哭了。
可以修改,但是按照期刊的意思,是连给重投的机会都没了。
主要是,我觉得这个审稿人审稿意见太那个了吧。。。。
我是有些心有不甘,想再试一下,申诉一下,起码找两个审稿人吧?一个人就直接给我毙了。