这种情况申诉的概率大不
审稿人没拒,编辑直接拒了。如下:
We have now considered your paper, and I regret to inform you that we not do find it suitable for publication in Polymer Reviews. We believe that it is too similar to your recent publication in ----, as pointed out by Reviewer 2 (see below) to warrant publication in Polymer Reviews.
审稿人1: However, there are some mistakes in the manuscript, such as 'fileds' and so on. Please check this manuscript carefully. After being revised, this manuscript can be published in Polymer Reviews.
审稿人2: Overall, the manuscript is a good review with clear figure/table, appropriate references and well written
I listed below a few questions and remarks, which the authors might wish to consider:
1- Regarding the positioning of this manuscript, this review follow a recent review on --- from the same authors, titled “---”. The authors may refer to their preview review to emphasize the new focus on --- applied to ---.
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
,