虫友，帮忙看看MSEA论文返修意见
8.6提交的论文，11号underreview，18号编辑给了mandatory revision，这个是啥意思？只知道小修大修，审稿人给了三条简单的意见，都好改。但编辑说了两条，一个是让我给试样的几何形状？我在实验部分说了是矩形试样，并给了具体尺寸，这是要我照个照片？第二条是说让结果和讨论分开写，没有经验，求虫友们帮忙看看
The report was positive and the reviewer indicated that the paper should be published after a few additions/corrections are made .The following are the mandatory revisions taken from this review.?It will be considered for publication in MSEA provided that it is revised in accord with any below comments of the reviewer or any additional comments and or corrections in the "Reviewer Attachments".
Editors Notes: (1) Please give the actual test sample geometries, and (2) The current MSE A policy is to report the "Results and Discussion" as two separate sections, please revise your manuscript in accordance with this procedure if separation can be reasonably accomplished.?
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
另外我看最近MSEA发表的论文很多都没有把结果results和discussion分开，怎么办呢？
按他要求来就行 我老师还说论文中不能出现i we 但是还不是有很多we 每个老师有自己特色
mandatory revision 应该是 强制修改 不改不行吧
编辑的意见并没什么困难的，到了这一步图省事要吃教训的
楼主注意“mandatory revision”，强制修订，而且已经说明了the paper should be published after a few additions/corrections are made ，所以编辑说什么就老老实实改什么吧。
对于编辑提出的两个要求
1. 建议展示测试样品的照片，并将原文中的描述向其说明；
2. "Results and Discussion" as two separate sections，编辑既然提出这一点，楼主可查询你所投期刊的往期文章，下载几篇结果与讨论分开写的文献，参考一下别人是怎么写的。Results描述各项实验结果，各个论点，Discussion描述结果（论点）之间的联系，研究结果的意义，