After?editorial?review,?I?have?determined?that?I?cannot?accept?your?paper?for?publication?in?Optics?Express.?

A?paper?is?acceptable?for?publication?in?Optics?Express?only?if?there?is?convincing?evidence?that,?in?addition?to?being?correct?technically,?it?also?adds?a?new?and?important?result?to?the?field.??I?have?found?that?your?paper?does?not?meet?this?criterion.??Dual?toroidal?resonances?in?flexible?metasurfaces?have?been?already?introduced?recently?by?the?authors?in?Ref.?41,?with?extremely?similar?phenomenology;?and?the?slight?variation?in?the?design?presented?here?does?not?provide?significant?new?results.??

The?Journal’s?editorial?board?discourages?resubmission?of?inadequately?revised?rejected?manuscripts.??Such?papers?may?be?rejected?without?being?sent?for?peer?review?unless?the?authors?can?show?that?the?resubmitted?paper?differs?significantly?from?the?original?one.

Thank?you?for?submitting?your?paper?to?Optics?Express.??I?regret?that?it?is?not?possible?to?send?you?a?more?favorable?report?on?this?manuscript,?and?I?hope?that?you?will?continue?to?consider?Optics?Express?for?future?submissions.

OSA?has?launched?a?new?Open?Access?journal,?OSA?Continuum,?that?will?consider?research?articles?meeting?OSA's?high?standa

 返回小木虫查看更多