投JPCL,审稿意见两个小修,返回去之后还会不会有其他审稿人啊??
小弟第一次投稿,投JPCL,投出去快一个月收到审稿意见
Dear Dr. XXX:
Thank you for submitting your manuscript for publication in The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters. It has been examined by expert reviewers who have concluded that the work is of potential interest to the readership of The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters.
As indicated in the enclosed comments, the reviewers' comments weregenerally positive, but certain improvements are suggested. I would be pleased to consider further for publication a revised manuscript that addresses the reviewers' concerns.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reviewer: 1
Recommendation: This paper is publishable subject to minor revisions noted. Further review is not needed.
Additional Questions:
Urgency: Moderate
Significance: High
Novelty: High
Scholarly Presentation: High
Is the paper likely to interest a substantial number of physical chemists, not just specialists working in the authors' area of research?: Yes
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reviewer: 2
Recommendation: This paper is publishable subject to minor revisions noted. Further review is not needed.
Additional Questions:
Urgency: High
Significance: High
Novelty: High
Scholarly Presentation: High
Is the paper likely to interest a substantial number of physical chemists, not just specialists working in the authors' area of research?: Yes
其中第二个审稿人还让我引用他的文章
审稿问题我回答得挺好的,文章也弄得不错了。求问这样子改完发回去以后,编辑会怎么处理啊?会不会再找除了第一次之外的其他审稿人啊?不想夜长梦
感谢各位大佬答疑多,
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
让你引用文章就引用吧,感觉审稿意见挺正面的,一般是直接返回给原审稿人,录用希望很大,加油,
基本上不会给新的审稿人了。
不会再送审,除非编辑很不满意你的回复
改完发回去以后编辑会很快接收的因为审稿人都说 Further review is not needed.