Initial assessment 是评估你提交的完整性。 With editor是编辑考虑你手稿的内容，With editor可能会拒稿
ps投稿系统都有说明吧

引用回帖:

2楼: Originally posted by 杳浅墨 at 2019-03-07 22:36:47
Initial assessment 是评估你提交的完整性。 With editor是编辑考虑你手稿的内容，With editor可能会拒稿
ps投稿系统都有说明吧

但是在 Initial assessment 之前 还有一个状态，是Checking submission and files，解释是 “we are checking to see if your submission is complete and we have all the files we need”。
系统里对Initial assessment 的解释是 “We are committed to publishing high quality new work that makes a significant contribution within the scope of its journals. In order to meet this aim, submitted manuscripts undergo initial evaluation by an editor to ensure that they meet essential criteria for publication in the journal. Only those manuscripts that pass this initial review process will be forwarded to reviewers for further consideration.”

对“with editor”的解释 是“manuscript is with the editor, either to select new or additional reviewers, or to make a decision following initial assessment or peer review”

难道这个 Initial assessment 不是 editor 做的么？如果做完的话可以直接 送审还是拒绝啊，为什么还要 with editor 呢
，

祝福

祝福