投稿得到邮件回复,邮件内容里含reviewer的comment, 邮件附件还有一个comment的文件
投稿IEEE ACCESS得到邮件回复,邮件内容里含几个reviewer的comment:
Reviewer: 1
Comments:
The paper considers 。。。。。。。。。, but not mention several processes that are crucial for the technical and theoretical support of the work. Many processes or steps are not mentioned, 。。。。。
Reviewer: 2
Comments:
This paper presents。。。。。。。。。。。. The method was introduced in detail in Section 2 and Section 3. But I think the paper needs to be further revised before it can be accepted.
1. The research background was not introduced and analyzed throughly in the Introduction part.
2. The Conclusions part should conclude the whole paper concisely and generally.
邮件附件还有一个单独的命名为comment的文件,内容直接是:
1、问题1
2、问题2
。。。。
都是非常具体的问题
不明白,这个单独的命名为comment的文件是审稿人的具体意见么?是不是修改的时候参照这个名为comment的文件就可以了
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
又或者这个comment文件是编辑的意见? 一头雾水
都回复就行,问啥回答啥
只要是审稿意见,不管在邮件中,还是附件中都需要一一回复
祝福
都要参考
你可以仔细看看,附件文件里是不是跟邮件comment是一样的修改意见。一般谨慎的发邮件者会同时将附件内容在邮件回复中粘贴,避免对方忙的没时间看附件而遗漏附件内容。所有的意见都需要一一回复,