编辑对论文语言的要求,前后矛盾,怎么解决
本人最近在Journal of Aerospace Engineering上投了一篇稿子,投稿前使用AJE对文章进行了润色。编辑挑了一些格式上的错误,驳回修改。我修改完以后,编辑把文章发给主编,主编把文章给拒了,理由是:
While the topic is potentially interesting, the language is below the readability level required for a major journal. Therefore, the paper needs to be edited and resubmitted before it can be sent out for review and consideration for publication. If possible, please have a copy editor or someone who is highly fluent in English review and edit the paper to improve the grammar and readability. If you do not have anyone who can help you, please visit our website at https://ascelibrary.org/page/englishlanguageeditingservices for a list of language cleanup services.
我打开他给的推荐网页,里面推荐的第一个润色公司就是AJE。我就回复了编辑,说我已经使用了AJE润色过了,还附上了AJE的证书。今天编辑回复我了,说还是不接受审稿,理由是:
I have been in touch with the editors, and while they would like you to improve the language of your paper, you will not have to send it back to AJE. The assistant to the Chief Editor is working with an AE who is a subject area expert to prepare a document with more specific suggestions for polishing the language in your paper; we hope to have it for you soon.
请问大家,他们为什么不让我找AJE?他是要为我修改稿件吗?内心非常复杂、混乱@Monash2011
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
推荐的人可能可以提出更具体建议(specific suggestion)
AJE的润色是真的很一般,我也是被审稿一直说,让修改语言
推荐的人如果能提实实在在的建议就太好了。会不会这个期刊和润色公司有协议,他们的稿子必须拉到润色公司才能送审
,
我觉得还是文章可读性差了点吧,润色公司很难从专业上帮你修改的,一般是语法上和用词上。
新北科研 英语母语外籍人士,专业英文文章润色,有意联系!