Dear Prof. Dr. *:

We are returning your manuscript "Unidirectional propagation of***", JAP18-AR-03991R, for minor improvements in Figs. 4-6 and the associated discussion.

The scale bar in Figs. 4 and 6 presumably refers to the amplitude of the electric field, and should be labeled as such in the caption. The "max" and "min" of the scale bars would then be explained. At the moment it is not clear whether "max" and "min" refer to field or intensity.

Also, "light energy" is presumably intensity? Finally, make sure that the labels in these figures use a font that is large enough so the labels will remain readable when they are reduced for publication.

When these changes are implemented, we will continue the publication process.

When you respond, please indicate how the manuscript has been revised in your response letter so that the editors can see whether you have complied with the reviewer comments.

The revised manuscript should be returned to the Editor promptly. Your revised manuscript is due 20-Nov-2018. A manuscript returned after 20-Nov-2018 will generally be regarded as new submission and will be assigned a new receipt date.




副主编决定信给了When these changes are implemented, we will continue the publication process

Stage        Start Date
Reviewer Assignment Started        29-Oct-2018 11:47:20
Securing Associate Editor        29-Oct-2018 11:47:19
Securing Editor        29-Oct-2018 11:47:19
Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed        29-Oct-2018 11:47:19
Manuscript File Replaced        26-Oct-2018 11:29:18
Submission Check by Editorial Office Started        25-Oct-2018 10:33:07
Securing Editor        25-Oct-2018 10:33:07
Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office        25-Oct-2018 10:33:05
Waiting for File Conversion        25-Oct-2018 10:14:39
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted        25-Oct-2018 10:02:05 返回小木虫查看更多