投稿后 编辑的建议 大家看看还有希望吗
前一阵投稿 journal of materials science
6.13 submitted
6.15 under consideration
6.17 under consideration
6.23 under consideration
6.25 Rejected
编辑的意见是实验图片和语言有问题,给出语言润色的建议,目前文章已在如下编辑建议的润色机构润色,几天后才能拿到结果,大家帮忙看看文章继续投这个期刊还有希望吗?
Dear Dr. **,
Your submission to the Journal of Materials Science with the title "**" (JMSC-D-18-**) has now been evaluated. Unfortunately, your manuscript cannot be further considered for publication. The reasons for this decision are given under Comments for the Authors below.
Resubmission to Journal of Materials Science: The resubmission of manuscripts previously considered and declined for publication in the Journal of Materials Science is discouraged, unless specifically invited by the handling editor.
With kind regards,
Saraswathi Sabapathy
JEO Assistant
Journal of Materials Science
COMMENTS FOR THE AUTHORS:
Thank you for your submission to the Journal of Materials Science. Unfortunately, there were several issues with the manuscript, listed below, that prevent it from being further considered for publication.
The English in the manuscript needs considerable improvement. There were many errors in word form, use of articles ('a', 'an', 'the'), and use of correct number (singular vs plural). You can have a colleague who is a native English speaker review your manuscript. Alternatively, Springer offers professional copy editing services through the Nature Research Editing Service <https://www.authorservices.springernature.com/> and American Journal Experts <https://www.aje.com/>, but you would have to bear the charge for this service. The use of a language editing service is not a requirement for publication in this journal and does not imply or guarantee that the article will be selected for peer review or accepted.
The machine-generated information should be removed from your micrographs and legible scale bars added to the images. This can easily be done using freeware programs like ImageJ.
20180625
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
Rejected就是拒稿了 还想啥呢 投别的期刊 记得cover letter改一下期刊名
最好再润色一下 编辑闲你写得太烂了
编辑说不让你重投
没什么希望了。语言差了一些,润色后转投吧。
但我的理解是按照编辑的意思修改和润色后 再给编辑看 看他建议重投与否?不知我的理解有误吗 因为 我看了其他投稿经验 直接拒没有建议语言润色 既然建议我语言润色说明我文章的创新性还是可以的
,
我觉得不要再投这个期刊了,他只是委婉的表达了据稿,个人意见。
不知道你投的这个期刊对英语要求有多严格,但是编辑就据稿了,就表示根本没到审稿人手里,对你文章的创新性编辑应该没看,创新性和理论数据问题是审稿人看的。
再投一个别的期刊会好一点。