被编辑拒稿求分析
人生第一次投稿,选了ACS的macromolecules,三四天编辑就给拒了,拒稿邮件如下:
Thank you for considering Macromolecules for your manuscript submission. I have examined your manuscript before deciding to send it out for external review. In my judgment, your submission is unlikely to receive sufficiently favorable reviews to support publication in Macromolecules, and would likely not achieve the broad appeal and impact expected for works published in Macromolecules. In particular the area of polyaniline/graphene capacitors has seen considerable attention and has even been recently reviewed. As a result, although I am sure you are advancing this area, I find your manuscript is better suited for a more specialized journal in the energy field. As I am sure you can appreciate, we receive many more submissions than we can possibly accept for publication. Consequently, I must decline your manuscript. Thank you for your interest in Macromolecules.
按照我的理解,编辑是认可我的工作但是觉得水平不高,我是不是应该改投一些低一档的期刊?求各位指点。
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
邮件就是这些内容,我只是略去了他举例的那篇综述的名字
,
感觉就是套话,都是有模板的,改投就是了
认可工作也是客套话,主要方向不是很合编辑口味,改投吧
能源类期刊更适合你的文章
明显的拒稿,改投其他期刊吧,靠近能源专业类的
换一家