当前位置: 首页 > 论文投稿 >老师们帮忙看看是什么意思?

老师们帮忙看看是什么意思?

作者 孤星
来源: 小木虫 900 18 举报帖子
+关注

第一次投稿,英语水平有限,请各位老师,前辈帮忙看一下这个是什么意思?最开始好像写了不能在EMC 发表,后面又好像说改过后可以考虑发表,也要求返回三个修改文件,不知到底是什么情况?修改提交后接受机会大吗?最主要“Therefore, the paper cannot be published in Energy Conversion and Management as it is presented.”这句话怎么理解?
Thank you for sending the manuscript/revised manuscript, ",,,,,,,,,,,,,,," to Energy Conversion and Management for publication.  I apologize for the lengthy period of review. The review is now complete, and unfortunately, it is not completely favorable. Therefore, the paper cannot be published in Energy Conversion and Management as it is presented. I have consolidated the review comments below in the hope that they   will be helpful to you in modifying the paper.

I hope these comments will be helpful to you. My sense of the reviewers' comments is that there is a very good basis on which I can recommend that this paper be modified in a responsive manner to the comments above.

In the revision process we would like to request you return three files:

If the modification is done carefully and completely, upon re-submission and evaluation, I think you can be confident that the paper will be accepted for publication in Energy Conversion and Management. Thank you again for sending this paper to Energy Conversion and Management for consideration.
谢谢各位老师的帮忙
 返回小木虫查看更多

今日热帖
  • 精华评论
  • lxying

    个人感觉这次是Rej了,但是鼓励你按照审稿人意见修改(应该是大修了)之后再投稿该杂志。至于你说的三个文件不知道是什么(你删去了?)

  • 孤星

    引用回帖:
    11楼: Originally posted by lxying at 2018-06-27 16:57:05
    个人感觉这次是Rej了,但是鼓励你按照审稿人意见修改(应该是大修了)之后再投稿该杂志。至于你说的三个文件不知道是什么(你删去了?)

    In the revision process we would like to request you return three files:
    (1) Please submit a list or table of changes (or your rebuttal) against each point raised when you upload your revised article and upload this as your 'Response to Reviewers' file/doc - note our system will not allow you to complete the resubmission process without this file.
    (2) Also please highlight any revised text using coloured highlighting in a separate word document.  This will enable the Editor /Reviewers to identify the amendments and subsequently make faster decisions on the revisions.
    (3) In addition we request one final file, a 'clean' word document of the revised manuscript without any annotations, highlighting or comments, in font 10 or 12 pt with double line spacing.
    要求回复就这三个文件

  • lxying

    引用回帖:
    12楼: Originally posted by 孤星 at 2018-06-27 17:08:29
    In the revision process we would like to request you return three files:
    (1) Please submit a list or table of changes (or your rebuttal) against each point raised when you upload your revised artic ...

    (1)这里给了一个revised,应该是给你一个修改的机会。要求你上传一个文件(命名为Response to Reviewers),逐一说明修改的地方(往往是依据审稿人的意见进行修改,所以先整理好审稿人的意见,一条一条整理好并编号,然后按照意见逐条回复、修改论文内容,对审稿人意见持不同观点的可以辩解说明(一定要有理有据、不卑不亢,充分尊重审稿人意见)。据我的经验,每一个审稿人的意见都给出逐条编号1,2,3........,逐条回复。回复之后一定要对审稿人的意见和编辑的辛劳表示感谢。
    (2)上传修改稿,能体现修改的地方(我一般用红色表示),编辑和审稿人一看便知你哪些地方修改了。
    (3)上传一个干净的稿件文件(修改之后的,个人认为与上边第二个一样,就是不用红色表示),用10或者12字号、双倍间距。(这个一般是接受之后便于后期编辑排版使用的)。

    希望能帮到你!

  • nono2009

    那句话是让你修改(无论大修还是小修)的套话,不是拒稿。好好修改便是,录用机会很大的。

    ECM的最新影响因子已经过6了,祝好运。

  • paperhunter

    编辑的意思是说以目前稿件的状态不适合发表,不过经过到位的修改是可以被接收的。不属于拒稿重投,楼主要参考审稿意见仔细修改,认真回复,修改到位接收的希望很大。

猜你喜欢
下载小木虫APP
与700万科研达人随时交流
  • 二维码
  • IOS
  • 安卓