投稿journal of experimental botany,求大家看看这个意见是否鼓励重投
Thank you for submitting your revised manuscript to the Journal of Experimental Botany. It was now reviewed again by both original referees, and as they strongly disagree in their judgement, I finally asked a colleague from the editorial board for a further evaluation. While I think that the work could lead to important results, I have to agree with the more critical reviewer and the editor colleague that in the current state the data are not convincing enough. In particular, *** Furthermore, I agree with the comments of the editor colleague, who wrote (citation): ***
As Journal of Experimental Botany allows only one round of major revisions, I can only reject your manuscript now.
We are sorry that we cannot be more positive on this occasion and hope you will consider submitting future work to the JXB.
最后一句虽然说了hope you will consider submitting future work to the JXB.但是不清楚这是不是一句客气话,还是鼓励重投。请有经验的朋友来指点下,万分感谢。
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
第二轮审稿两个审稿人意见不一致,责编请一个编委仲裁,审稿意见趋向负面,责编拒稿但没有鼓励重投。
感谢解答。
这种情况下即使按照要求补实验重投也没太大作用了吧。感觉不改投其他期刊似乎不行了
,
祝福