当前位置: 首页 > 论文投稿 >Subsequent decisions after one RQ should be AQ, A, or R only.这是什么意思?

Subsequent decisions after one RQ should be AQ, A, or R only.这是什么意思?

作者 angleboy
来源: 小木虫 400 8 举报帖子
+关注

期刊编辑有一行话:
Please remember that the Associate Editor should only decide RQ (major revision) once during the peer review process of any paper. Subsequent decisions after one RQ should be AQ, A, or R only.
其中,AQ,A,R代表什么意思? 返回小木虫查看更多

今日热帖
  • 精华评论
  • 13972033882

    修改后接受,直接接受,拒绝。我猜的

  • nono2009

    AQ 不清楚,可能是小修
    A = accept
    R = reject

  • Godblesswz

    1. R - Rejected: to reject the paper. Manuscripts that fall into this category will fail to meet the criteria of novelty and appropriateness, may be poorly written or targeted for a different audience, or require such significant editing that the edit cannot reasonably occur in the timeframe the author is allotted for revision. The reasoning for a Reject decision should be made clear in the AE’s comments. AEs may encourage resubmission in the decision letter if they feel that is appropriate.
    A - Accepted: to accept the paper with no changes. This manuscript requires no additional reviews, although there may be some small fixes--typos, etc.--which the AE indicates must be corrected. This manuscript will, essentially, be published "as is," with no additional action by the reviewers or AE.

    2. RQ - Major Revision: to request major, required revisions that will facilitate a second full review cycle by the original reviewers. This manuscript, although meeting the criteria of novelty and appropriateness, is seriously flawed as to disclosure (either technical or literary or both), and requires a major rework by the author.

    3. AQ - Accepted with Mandatory Revisions: to accept the paper with minor but required changes. This manuscript meets the criteria of novelty and appropriateness, but requires a few fixes, usually of the technical variety (more than typos or grammatical corrections). This decision should not be used if the AE wishes to return the manuscript to any or all of the reviewers; instead, the AE will check for the changes him/herself when the authors submit their revised version.

    4.  AQE - Accept with Mandatory Minor Revisions Including English Usage: to accept the paper with minor but required changes, specifically regarding the use of English in the manuscript. This manuscript meets the criteria of novelty and appropriateness, but requires a few fixes, usually typos or grammatical corrections. The authors are not required to use an English language editing service at this time. This decision should not be used if the AE wishes to return the manuscript to any or all of the reviewers; instead, the AE will check for the changes him/herself when the authors submit their revised version.

    5. AQE2 (**only after AQE decision has already been given previously) - to accept the paper with minor but required changes, specifically regarding the use of English in the manuscript, This decision requires authors to send their paper to American Journal Experts (AJE) or another professional English editing service for English editing before it can be formally accepted. The AQE2 should only be used after an AQE decision has already been given to the authors once. It is the responsibility of the author(s) to provide supporting documentation as proof that the manuscript was reviewed by AJE. This decision should not be used if the AE wishes to return the manuscript to any or all of the reviewers; instead, the AE will check for the changes him/herself when the authors submit their revised version,

  • Godblesswz

    1. R - Rejected: to reject the paper. Manuscripts that fall into this category will fail to meet the criteria of novelty and appropriateness, may be poorly written or targeted for a different audience, or require such significant editing that the edit cannot reasonably occur in the timeframe the author is allotted for revision. The reasoning for a Reject decision should be made clear in the AE’s comments. AEs may encourage resubmission in the decision letter if they feel that is appropriate.

    2. A - Accepted: to accept the paper with no changes. This manuscript requires no additional reviews, although there may be some small fixes--typos, etc.--which the AE indicates must be corrected. This manuscript will, essentially, be published "as is," with no additional action by the reviewers or AE.

    3. RQ - Major Revision: to request major, required revisions that will facilitate a second full review cycle by the original reviewers. This manuscript, although meeting the criteria of novelty and appropriateness, is seriously flawed as to disclosure (either technical or literary or both), and requires a major rework by the author.

    4. AQ - Accepted with Mandatory Revisions: to accept the paper with minor but required changes. This manuscript meets the criteria of novelty and appropriateness, but requires a few fixes, usually of the technical variety (more than typos or grammatical corrections). This decision should not be used if the AE wishes to return the manuscript to any or all of the reviewers; instead, the AE will check for the changes him/herself when the authors submit their revised version.

猜你喜欢
下载小木虫APP
与700万科研达人随时交流
  • 二维码
  • IOS
  • 安卓