Major Revision,期刊编辑的邮件如下所示,不知是凶是吉啊,望大神们给分析一下
I am forwarding you constructive suggestions from the reviewers and/or Associate Editor to improve your manuscript. The comments are at the end of this letter and/or in attached files.
Please work directly with the Associate Editor, Dr. Ganesh Bora (gcbora@abe.msstate.edu), as you make your revisions. Include with your resubmission an itemized response to each reviewer comment. Your revised manuscript and your responses to the reviewers' comments will be sent to the Associate Editor when you submit them via your Author Center.
The final decision regarding publication will be contingent on your revisions and responses to the issues raised by the reviewers.
We would appreciate the return of the revised manuscript within four weeks. ASABE policy is that manuscripts not revised within two months will be withdrawn, unless more time is granted by the Editor. If you have circumstances such that you need more time for revision, please contact me about a time extension.
Thank you for submitting your manuscript to Transactions of the ASABE.
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
这是正常的修改邮件
就是教你修改的模版邮件。成功几率要看reviewer’s comments。这种杂志,一一修改,成功几率应该挺高的
,
大修啊70%机会吧。
不要怕major。
我最近当editor,为了敦促作者认真改,都倾向于给major,即使有一个reviewer的建议minor。
你投的什么期刊?