针对一篇17年的德国应用化学，觉得那篇文章漏洞明显，写了这篇文章。

先投journal of catalysis，审稿两个月，悲剧。

直接转投亚洲化学，

18号投，25号接收，
推荐封面。

人生第一篇直接接收！仅用了不到一周时间。

还算比较给力吧。


怎么总感觉亏了。

即便被JC锯掉，也应该试试其他同档次的。

有些可惜了。

REVIEWER REPORT

EVALUATION:

Reviewer's Responses to Questions

1. Please rate the importance of the reported results

Reviewer #1: Highly important (top 10%)

Reviewer #2: Important



2. Please rate the citation of previous publications

Reviewer #1: Appropriate

Reviewer #2: Appropriate


3. Please rate the length of the manuscript

Reviewer #1: Concise

Reviewer #2: Concise


4. Please rate the verification of hypotheses and conclusions by the presented data

Reviewer #1: Minor inconsistencies

Reviewer #2: Fully consistent


5. Please indicate which other journal you consider more appropriate

Reviewer #1:
*ChemCatChem

Reviewer #2:
*---- 返回小木虫查看更多