当前位置: 首页 > 论文投稿 >投了一篇期刊,经过两轮修改被拒了,还有必要重投吗?

投了一篇期刊,经过两轮修改被拒了,还有必要重投吗?

作者 alix08
来源: 小木虫 400 8 举报帖子
+关注

这是被拒的理由:
Dear Dr.  ,

We now have reviewers' comments on the above paper and I regret to inform you that it is not considered suitable for publication in Ironmaking and Steelmaking: Processes, Products and Applications. The reason is explained below and is related to the poor English language as applied.

We are sorry not to be able to write in a more positive way but we should like to thank you for giving us an opportunity to consider your work for publication.

Reviewers' comments:

Reviewer #1: Dear authors,

please send your manuscript to a professional translator or a native speaker to revise the text. The level of English is still not good enough for publication.
In my previous comments I already suggested to improve the English and I gave a few examples of poor English in the text. Unfortunately only the highlighted sentences were improved, but the rest of the text was not revised. For example, I suggested to change "athmosphere pressure" to "atmospheric pressure" at line 14 on page 4. You did follow my suggestion there, but at page 5 line 16 it still says "atmosphere pressure".

Apart from the level of English I am satisfied with the paper.

   最后还给推荐了润色服务公司。
   请问各位大神还有必要重投吗??? 返回小木虫查看更多

今日热帖
  • 精华评论
  • arronlhl

    为啥第一次不润色彻底,这拒稿好可惜

  • siwaxingge122

    完全是英语水平的问题,写文章太可惜了。

  • wonderfulll

    这也太坑了吧……

  • first-love

    活该,修改论文不彻底,这种态度不端正的下次长点心

  • bobvan

    是个审稿人都会据稿的,因为楼主根本没有用心按审稿意见去提高文章的英语水平,这次算是吃一堑长一智
    不过编辑推荐了润色公司,花钱润色一下,再附上润色证明,重投应该还是有机会,

  • ydyxjun

    如果我是审稿人,我也会拒。

  • zhaopch_2015

    润色重投吧,因为语言确实太可惜了

猜你喜欢