ACS marco letters 6审稿人,其中一个以不适合杂志要求拒稿,如何回复
6个审稿人,3个小修,2个大修,还有一个以不适合拒。拒绝理由如下
“The manuscript does not meet the requirements of urgency and novelty that justify its publication.”
求,该如何回应?
返回小木虫查看更多
今日热帖
6个审稿人,3个小修,2个大修,还有一个以不适合拒。拒绝理由如下
“The manuscript does not meet the requirements of urgency and novelty that justify its publication.”
求,该如何回应?
返回小木虫查看更多
因为是文章,就要求创新性(novelty);因为是letters类的期刊,就是要求稿件尽快刊出(urgency)。个人以为,只要将文章的创新性以及研究结果对他人在相近领域的研究能够起到的的帮助做一个清楚的阐述,也就否定性地回答了“The manuscript does not meet the requirements of urgency and novelty that justify its publication”这个问题。就是因为能够对别人有较大的帮助,所以需要尽快接受并刊罚�
祝福
祝楼主顺利