转一个搜到的08年的标准。
1. Trivial or wrong or known.
Clearly below AAAI threshold, I assume no further discussion is needed.
2. A strong rejection.
I will strongly argue for rejection.
3. A clear rejection.
I vote and argue for rejection.
4. An OK paper, but not good enough. A rejection.
I vote for rejecting it, although would not be upset if it were accepted.
5. Marginally below the acceptance threshold.
I tend to vote for rejecting it, but having it in the program would not be that bad.
6. Marginally above the acceptance threshold.
I tend to vote for accepting it, but leaving it out of the program would be no great loss.
7. Good paper, accept.
I vote for acceptance, although would not be upset if it were rejected.
8. Top 50% of accepted AAAI papers, a very good paper, a clear accept.
I vote and argue for acceptance.
9. Top 15% of accepted AAAI papers, an excellent paper, a strong accept.
I will fight for acceptance.
10. Top 5% of accepted AAAI papers, a seminal paper for the ages.
Clearly an outstanding paper. I assume no further discussion is needed.
唉,没戏了,一个accept,一个marginally below,一个reject,都没有必要argue了。。
我是一个accept,一个marginally above,一个clear reject,基本没戏
2个marginally above,1个marginally below,基本没戏。。
是只要有below就没戏了吗
转一个搜到的08年的标准。
1. Trivial or wrong or known.
Clearly below AAAI threshold, I assume no further discussion is needed.
2. A strong rejection.
I will strongly argue for rejection.
3. A clear rejection.
I vote and argue for rejection.
4. An OK paper, but not good enough. A rejection.
I vote for rejecting it, although would not be upset if it were accepted.
5. Marginally below the acceptance threshold.
I tend to vote for rejecting it, but having it in the program would not be that bad.
6. Marginally above the acceptance threshold.
I tend to vote for accepting it, but leaving it out of the program would be no great loss.
7. Good paper, accept.
I vote for acceptance, although would not be upset if it were rejected.
8. Top 50% of accepted AAAI papers, a very good paper, a clear accept.
I vote and argue for acceptance.
9. Top 15% of accepted AAAI papers, an excellent paper, a strong accept.
I will fight for acceptance.
10. Top 5% of accepted AAAI papers, a seminal paper for the ages.
Clearly an outstanding paper. I assume no further discussion is needed.
,