编辑给的moderate revision，是适当修改还是中修？
编辑给的意见是moderate revision，通知如下our reviewers have raised minor objections to the current draft for publication。In particular, a potential revised manuscript should improve the English grammar and expressions used in the paper and make the writing style of the paper more suitable for a journal paper.
一个审稿意见Aside from some minor grammatical errors, the paper is acceptable in its present form.?
第二个审稿人意见， 让大修，Overall, this is a very good reservoir characterization paper with abundant data. However, there are still some questions:?This paper need be rewritten using proper and concise English, and some sentences are hard to be understood. The writing style in this paper looks like a technical report but not a journal paper.?My suggestion is "major revision"?。
第三个意见In my opinion the manuscript is interesting but it is very long and should be reduced in its pages number. Additionally, English should be improved.?所以想请教一下，是适当修改还是中修？

 返回小木虫查看更多