编辑部回信,几个意思?
各位大牛,帮忙看看,昨天收到编辑部回信,这个届时录用的概率有多大?谢谢!
回信内容如下:
Dear Mr. XXX,
please accept our sincere apologies for not responding, ....
Regarding your manuscript entitled "XXXXXX", it was accepted for the publication in the XXX after some necessary adjustments to your manuscript according to the internal review by Editorial Board. However, currently, around 80-100 earlier manuscripts are in the review process. Since we publish approximately 40 papers per year, therefore, your manuscript can be published no earlier than 2019-2020.
If you agree with these conditions, before we can start with the review process, please re-write your manuscript according to "Instructions for authors" (https://..., or use our Template (http:...).
The Abstract should have at least 200 words.
The total length of an article, including illustrations and tables to be inserted in the text, should not exceed 15 pages of A4 format.
Regarding References, only the author-date system of references style (Harvard or APA style) is acceptable, therefore, please correct the system of citations in your manuscript. At the same time, we would be very grateful if you could use the possibility to cite some of relevant works published in the Acta Montanistica Slovaca Journal during last two years, if possible.
Also, please check English language in the manuscript.
After you adjust it according to these instructions, we can start with the double blind peer review process prior to publication.
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
祝福必中
才技术关,早的很
祝福
It's not normal. I have experience publishing, editing and reviewing, and have never seen a letter like that. They ask you to cite works of the Acta Motanistica, obviously to increase their citation count. Normally, any good journal would not mention that, at least so explicitly. But I cannot tell much more with this little information. Perhaps this can help. Feel free to reply or contact me. Good luck
2019-2020年发表,楼主要注意时间周期哦。
1、这个期刊每年只出版40篇左右文章,楼主的文章不会早于2019-2020发表。
2、编辑的修改只是针对文章的格式或者参考文献引用方面的问题,不涉及到学术层面。
3、格式达到要求后才开始双盲审。
感觉前后说法不一,前面说根据编辑部内审结论,经过必要调整后文章可以发表,后面说在发表前还需要经过双盲审,如果是正规的期刊,无法判断录用概率。
1. 期刊每年发表约 40 篇文章,目前已有 80-100 篇论文在排队,楼主的文章最快也要 2019 或 2020 年才能发表
2. 在论文送审之前,请先根据期刊的规定修改论文:摘要至少 200 字以上、论文全场含图表不能超过 15 页
3. 参考文献采用 Harvard 或 APA 格式。如果可以的话,请引用 Acta Montanistica Slovaca Journal 发表过的相关文章
4. 检查语言
奇怪的地方在于,编辑开头说论文经过这些修改就可以准备接受,但最后又说修改后会进行双盲评审。楼主最好重复确认下这个期刊的正规性,