CEJ投稿问题,大神帮我看看,编辑这拒信我是重投还是另投
上个月末投的chemical engineering journal,选的是Environmental Chemical Engineering,编辑allen, 今天收到拒信,但是是香港的King Lun Yeung回的信,然后说我的稿子跟Chemical Reaction Engineering section不沾边.......囧,当然不沾边,我就不是投的这个,下边是拒信,大神帮我看看我是重投还是转投,因为里面有句The Journal also publishes contributions dealing with Materials Synthesis and Processing or Environmental Chemical Engineering, which are handled by other Editors. 是说我要找其他编辑?
Dear Dr. xxx,
I thank you for your recent contribution sent to the Chemical Engineering Journal. However, I have examined your manuscript and in my opinion the focus of your contribution is out of the scope of the Chemical Reaction Engineering section, as described in the Guide for Authors of the Chemical Engineering Journal (see description below).
Thus, at this stage, in spite of its interest, I have to withdraw your manuscript from further consideration.
I will be happy to process any future contributions from your laboratory dealing with Chemical Reaction Engineering, as described in the Guide for Authors. The Journal also publishes contributions dealing with Materials Synthesis and Processing or Environmental Chemical Engineering, which are handled by other Editors.
I am sorry not to have better news on this occasion and I thank you for choosing the Chemical Engineering Journal as a publishing medium.
Yours sincerely,
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
还是说文章太水的婉言啊
感觉全是套话
这个就是据稿的套话,LZ改投其他期刊吧
改投吧。CEJ要求很高的。。。编辑婉拒了,意思就是没到期刊标准
楼主是怎么做的?咱俩情况一样,我觉得就是搞错了
转投呗,应该就是觉得水平不够,客套话,我时间紧,等不及,如果你有时间可以试试给主编写信申述重投
楼主 你后来怎么办啦? 我这几天也被Allen主编直接拒稿了,就说创新点不够,建议transfer一下。但是我应该选主编的时候选择材料制备的那个主编 ,结果我选了环境化工的Allen主编。我很纠结要不要重新投,选材料制备那部分的主编哇,