三个审稿人、两个说可以修、最后一个强烈反对。编辑给了这样的意见、不知道是不是应该重投：

We are returning the comments of the reviewers.  In view of their recommendations, I cannot accept your manuscript for publication in Optics Letters.

I wish to add that the comments on your manuscript where extremely heterogenous. However, the breath of the comment from the referee that was rejecting the manuscript is quite intense and I, therefore, followed its advise. However, if you feel that you can rebuttal these comments and you can make appropriate changes to the manuscript, you can consider resubmitting the manuscript.  However, I stress the fact that the manuscript will be treated as a new submission and will be peer-reviewed in depth again. Likely with the same referees as of the previous manuscript. Therefore, please describe in an accompanying letter the changes you've made in the manuscript if you decide to so. Please do not just make cosmetic changes to the manuscript but take the comments seriously.  

Thank you for the opportunity to consider your contribution.  We regret that it was not possible for us to send you a more favorable report.

 返回小木虫查看更多