投稿Polymer今天被拒了,大牛帮忙看看审稿意见,接下来该怎么办呢?
Dear Professor,
Thank you for your interest in Polymer.
I have received your manuscript "Flow shear-induced ordered crystalline of silk fibroin on solid-liquid interface and its application on cotton fiber modification". However, after reading your paper, I feel that it should be published in a more applied journal. I have made no judgment as to the manuscript's quality.
Thank you for giving us the opportunity to consider your work. I hope that you will submit further papers in the future.
Please find below the "Comments to Author" for your information.
Yours sincerely,
Charles Han
All Papers from China: All Subject Areas
Polymer
Comments from the editor:
This paper shows a very interesting idea and some very qualitative results. At this stage , this paper is too qualitative and applied for the publication in the JPOL.
If the authors wish to try JPOL again, a detailed quanitive study, characterization and analysis are needed before re-submitting this paper.
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
JPOL的意思就是polymer吧? 因为他用了again
原话如下:
If the authors wish to try JPOL again,a detailed quanitive study, characterization and analysis are needed before re-submitting this paper
,
祝福
文章仅是定性方面的研究,缺乏定量的研究工作。
实验数据不足,好好改改,还是有希望的
文章内容偏应用 理论和的分析太少 如果可以补上可以再投
这期刊收费,不投也罢
没有实质的建议,就是说你定量的东西太少了。
话说,真不知道JPOL是哪刊....
polymer多久有了结果啊,您后来投的哪里