当前位置: 首页 > 论文投稿 >论文投稿一天编辑就返回意见

论文投稿一天编辑就返回意见

作者 hhhhh12138
来源: 小木虫 500 10 举报帖子
+关注

投稿Information Processing and Management.  晚上10点投稿,第二天上午十点编辑就返回意见。
编辑1意见:
Thank you for submitting your manuscript to Information Processing and Management. We have completed the review of your manuscript. A summary is appended below. While revising the paper please consider the reviewers' comments carefully. We look forward to receiving your detailed response and your revised manuscript.
Enrich your article to present your research with maximum impact. This journal supports the following Content Innovations:
  Explain your research in your own words and attract interest in your work using AudioSlides : 5-minute webcast-style presentations that are displayed next to your published article and can be posted on other websites. You will receive an invitation email to create an AudioSlides presentation within three weeks after your paper has been accepted.
   Interactive Plots: Interactive plot viewer providing easy access to the data behind plots. Please prepare a .CSV file with your plot data and test it online here before submitting as supplementary material.
I look forward to receiving your revised manuscript as soon as possible.
这是说幻灯片是必须做吗。。数据代码也必须共享?

编辑2意见:
I have had a chance to read through your manuscript. There are some changes you would need to address before the manuscript can be sent for formal review. Changes are:
- your abstract does not highlight the specifics of your research or findings
- there needs to be an explicit research objective stated, preferably as a separate section
- I really recommend that you follow a standard research manuscript format (abstract, intro, review, research questions, methods, results, implications, conclusion.
- your references are, for the most part, quite old. Certainly, there has been more recent (within the last two years) research on this  topic published in Information Processing and Management and other outlets. Therefore, you must update your literature review
- the manuscript requires a thorough copy editing
- your reference list need tidying up, as there are several references with missing items or formatting issues
- you must more clearly highlight the theoretical and practical implications of your research

Therefore, I invite you to respond to the comments and revise your manuscript. Please include a detailed response outlining the revisions that you did.

这是不是委婉的拒了呀。。 返回小木虫查看更多

今日热帖
  • 精华评论
  • 422094268

    幻灯片需要做的,如果你的论文接收,在三周之内你会收到相关email邀请。数据data需要,就是要你画图的那些data,估计编辑需要重新编辑排版。

  • 422094268

    编辑2的意思是让你按照规范写自己的论文。你的论文重点不是很清楚。编辑需要你按照一般论文规范写,这样你的文章逻辑更好。此外,编辑觉得你文献缺失不标准。不是婉拒相当于大修。希望楼主好好按照编辑们提出的问题一一对应修改,接受的概率很大的。

  • kmght

    编辑这关都还没过,好好按照意见改才能送审

  • mxnjfu

    认真修改完善。祝福!

  • hhhhh12138

    引用回帖:
    2楼: Originally posted by 422094268 at 2017-03-19 20:53:44
    幻灯片需要做的,如果你的论文接收,在三周之内你会收到相关email邀请。数据data需要,就是要你画图的那些data,估计编辑需要重新编辑排版。

    嗯嗯,明白啦,谢谢你,第一次投稿,啥都不懂

  • hhhhh12138

    引用回帖:
    3楼: Originally posted by 422094268 at 2017-03-19 21:00:01
    编辑2的意思是让你按照规范写自己的论文。你的论文重点不是很清楚。编辑需要你按照一般论文规范写,这样你的文章逻辑更好。此外,编辑觉得你文献缺失不标准。不是婉拒相当于大修。希望楼主好好按照编辑们提出的问题 ...

    好类,谢谢你~~好好改

猜你喜欢