OE投稿返回意见后,怎么确定是大修还是小修?3个审稿人都是正面的
如题,先给状态,只有10天时间,算今天也就8天了:
Author Revision 25 1月 2017
Preproduction Review 23 1月 2017 25 1月 2017 Author Revision
First Manuscript Decision 23 1月 2017 23 1月 2017 Provisional Acceptance
Rate Reviewers 23 1月 2017 23 1月 2017 Reviewer Rating Completed
Peer Review 11 1月 2017 23 1月 2017 Peer Review Complete
Assign Editor 05 1月 2017 11 1月 2017 Editor Assigned
Quality Check 03 1月 2017 05 1月 2017 Quality Check Passed
Submit Manuscript 30 12月 2016 03 1月 2017 Submission Complete
4个审稿人最终3个回复还有个始终too busy,3个回复意见都是正面的,但是提出的问题不算少,有部分重复
前面编辑说需要提交修改后的Manuscript和response,如下:
It is the policy of Optics Express to allow only one revision cycle. Thus, it is important to include as part of your resubmission a detailed response to all of the reviewer points. You will upload your response letter in the online system. Of course, you may not agree with the reviewers on every point and, in that case, your responses and reasoning should be clearly presented. Please note that a response letter is required before a final manuscript decision can be made.
我看了【File Upload】部分,没找到单独提交response的地方,只有Manuscript,
在Comments (optional)提到了:
Please be sure to upload your response to reviewers in the above File Upload section under file type “Author Response”. You may use the below section to provide additional comments about your submission for the journal editors and staff.
Comments的意思似乎是【File Upload】部分在提交manuscript的同时,提交对reviewer的response。
因为我都是用tex写的manuscript,也会用tex写response,一次性提交两个tex会不会导致冲突?
多谢各位关注,祝大家新年快乐哈!
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
你这个是小修,大修是major revison
非常感谢回复
我修改后的manuscript和对3个reviewers的response,是不是都写成tex后通过【File Upload】提交,如下图?
因为有3个reviewers,我是否要写成3个response,还是说我写1个合并的response,后面的拆分response让给编辑处理?
1.JPG
,
这个回复信就可以了,所有审稿人都看的到